Chapter 07 / Merit
Current Contribution and Lifetime Contribution
“A person's present work and their past contribution both deserve recognition.”
They do different jobs in the proposed economy. Current contribution reflects what the person can usefully do now. Accumulated merit preserves recognition of what they have already given over time.
The founding discussion proposes that revenue draw on both components, with current contribution receiving the larger share during working life. One example assigns 70% of working revenue to current contribution and 30% to accumulated merit. Another assigns two-thirds to current contribution and one-third to accumulated merit. The choice remains open.
Why two components matter
A system based entirely on present output could forget a lifetime of effort when someone slows down. A system based entirely on history could make new contributors wait too long for fair recognition and could reward an old record regardless of current responsibility.
The two-component approach tries to keep both concerns visible. Someone beginning a career can be recognized for a useful current role. Someone who has contributed steadily for years gains a lasting historical foundation. Changing work would affect the current assessment without automatically erasing the past.
This is the purpose of the proposal, not proof that a particular ratio will achieve it. The result depends on how both components are measured and funded. A reasonable-looking percentage can produce unreasonable outcomes if the underlying scales are poorly designed.
What the percentages do and do not tell us
Suppose, only to illustrate a split, that a hypothetical monthly revenue is one thousand accounting units. The 70/30 example assigns 700 units to current contribution and 300 to accumulated merit. A two-thirds division would attribute about six hundred and sixty-seven units to the first and three hundred and thirty-three to the second.
This example divides a total that has already been assumed. It does not explain how to determine that total, how a new worker qualifies for it, or how much either component can buy. The accounting units have no proposed exchange rate. They are used only to make the proportions clear.
An operating model must answer a deeper question: is revenue calculated by combining two independent assessments with weights, or is a person's total entitlement first established and then described in two parts? Those approaches are not interchangeable. The founding discussion has not chosen between them.
Building accumulated merit
Merit could accumulate by hour, month, or another defined period along a curve. The source leaves the interval and the curve open. The design has to decide what is being accumulated: hours alone, assessed contribution over time, or some other credited quantity.
Hours alone would be simple but would overlook differences in responsibility and usefulness. A fully individualized calculation could recognize those differences but become complex and vulnerable to inconsistent judgments. A model combining standard role-based credit with limited adjustments is another possibility. Each option requires comparison.
The shape of the curve matters too. A steadily rising curve may preserve recognition over a lifetime but create very large differences after long service. A curve with diminishing additions could limit that divergence but would need to show that long contribution still leads to adequate retirement. These are design choices to test, rather than settled features.
Interruptions raise further questions. Education, illness, caregiving, unemployment, and voluntary inactivity are different circumstances. The source does not state whether each earns historical credit. A future model should describe those periods explicitly instead of quietly treating every gap as failure to contribute.
Avoiding a closed hierarchy
Accumulation can become an obstacle to opportunity if seniority dominates every other consideration.
“A capable new worker should not need decades of history before their current contribution can support a good life.”
This is one reason the current component carries the larger proposed weight during working life.
Likewise, earlier merit should not give someone automatic authority in a different field. Economic recognition, professional competence, and eligibility for an elected responsibility are related but distinct matters. A high historical balance does not establish that someone is the right person to direct a particular service.
The recommended safeguard is to evaluate these questions separately and explain their relationships. The economic system should reward contribution without turning a record of past work into a general right to command others.
Records people can understand
A person should be able to see what period was assessed, what credit was recorded, and what effect it had on revenue. This manuscript proposes a personal account with clear statements, correction procedures, and limited access for officials performing a defined task.
That account need not expose a person's detailed health or family circumstances to employers or the public. The institution calculating an entitlement may need a verified status without receiving every sensitive detail behind it. Privacy and audit requirements have to be designed together.
Errors also need repair. Missing records, duplicated contributions, and incorrect classifications can change a person's long-term position. A correction should reach both the current payment and the historical record where appropriate.
The two components offer a useful way to discuss a lifetime of contribution. Their value will depend on whether people can understand them, whether newcomers have a fair start, and whether a long working life leads to dependable support when current work ends. Retirement therefore requires its own design, beyond the initial working-life percentages.
Questions for discussion
- Is the revenue balance 70/30, two-thirds/one-third, or something else?
- How does merit accumulate, and how does it convert into revenue?
Share an idea as a guest. Free accounts will open when account email is ready.
Ask a question or propose an idea
Download the paper
Version 0.15 · November 14, 2026
Democratic Meritocracy and the World Federated Economy
Revised manuscript · November 6, 2026